I don't know why people go on about how accurate or inaccurate they are, who cares that is just your opinion (which a million times a day will not match up exactly with someone elses). How about just posting your own list of the top 10 games of the year?
That way you won't have to have any disagreements with the list? The only list that I think has much validty is NGM's games list by how much they sold this year...

My 10 list is in no particular order
10. Final Fantasy X (ps2)
9. Red Faction 2 (ps2)
8. Socom (ps2)
7. Virtua Fighter 4 (ps2)
oh fuck this lol I can't think of ne more....