Honestly, I don't think it would take me more than 15 seconds or so at any point to be able to tell which of the three is which.

This was by far the most impressive battle scene I have seen to date, and the length of it was incredible! The only part of the entire movie that kind of ticked me off was after the battle was over and they went through the whole spleel with The Shire. It just seemed like it was in slow motion for like 45 minutes to me, but I guess it was good. At least they provided some sort of closure to the characters.

Overacting by the hobbits again, yes.

Cheers from the movie viewers in my theatre when Legolas took down the Mammoth as well, yes.

Great movie, yes.