Ugh.. So many stipulations, questionable content, side bars, and alternate ideas. Heh, if you want, either myself, or someone else, can read all the ideas in this thread and put together a revised proposition.

One which covers the council makeup, a council vote, member vote, Staff exclusion, judging system (Categories, etc. for judging), place for deliberation, what Forums to judge members in (Exclude WRT and Chat?), back-up council ideas (Penny's 3/5 system?), actual rating system in full (SoA, GAHH, BLIS, etc.), how the ratings will be implemented, how often a members posts will get judged, which posts will initially be judged (Last 50 posts, 25 posts?), how a member can lose particular ratings (For the better or worse), etc.

Is there anything else I'm missing? Once the final list of everything needed for discussion is put together, as I have started above, I will start the draft, or others if they want.