I'm honestly sorry dude. That really sucks. Hopefully it will still work out for you two. Nothing against the religious buffs or anything, but I can see how that might get on you. I'm atheist, for those who didn't know, and I absolutely hate when people try to push me towards god, so I can kind of feel where you're coming from, but that has to suck immensly more when it's from the girl you love so much. I don't know how I would handle it if a girlfriend of mine told me she loved god more than me, but since you believe in god it's probably a completely different scenario. It really does sound like she's asking too much from you at this age, especially since you two don't seem to share the exact same beliefs. Still, I hope it works out for you, man.

And just as a side-note, you don't sound like a pussy at all. I posted shit like this about a girl on this board, and she wasn't even my girlfriend. I will personally lynch anyone that says anything disparaging you because of this post.