Nobody specified that these characters had to be one decisive version of themselves. I said:

You contradicted that and I proved you wrong. Now you bitch about it being unfair? Please. You invited the argument. I said "if he has all of his abilities" and you challenged that statement. It's not my fault that you didn't think clearly about it before posting.

Don't go labelling something as stupid when you knew exactly what you were asking for. Just because you can't out-argue it doesn't mean you should whine about it.