Yes the motherboard does work when I take the RAM backout.

I thought about the bad stick, so I went and exchanged it today. Same problem.
I'll go ahead and take out the old stick, and leave the new one in. See if that does anything. Otherwise I'll just hold off, and get a matching pair like Adrena suggested.

Edit:

Works w/ the new stick. Definalty just like Adrena said, they are not compatible together. POS

Now if slaynish would just get on AIM...