Cloud vs. Squall vs. Zidane vs. Tidus

A massive four-way brawl in which three individuals, brandishing powerful blades, face off to the death!

Battle Participants

Cloud Strife
Final Fantasy: VII
Ultimate Weapon: Ultima Weapon
Background: Grew up in a small town called Nibleheim. Wishes to join SOLDIER. Never makes it. Used as a Sephiroth Clone by Professor Hojo. Fooled into believing he was in SOLDIER and given the memory of Zack.
Quest: Travelling to defeat Sephiroth. No, being summoned by Sephiroth. Escapes his influence and defeats Sephiroth.

Squall Leonhart-
Final Fantasy: VIII
Ultimate Weapon: Lionheart
Background: Grew up in Edea Krammar's orphange on the Centra continent. Taken by Balamb Garden. Has a great rivalry with Seifer Almasy. Stoic and anti-social, he eventually losens up due to Rinoa's influence.
Quest: Does a SeeD mission and gets sucked up into a giant plot by a sorceress from the future. Eventually exstinguishes the villain and that's all.

Zidane Triball-
Final Fantasy: IX
Ultimate Weapon: Ultima Weapon
Background: A specialized genome from another planet called Terra. Created by Garland, to be a "Angel of Death" to the people of Gaia. However, he forgets this and becomes a somewhat normal person.
Quest: On attempting to kidnap the princess, he is sucked into the events around him. Travels from place to place, just following what has been happening, motives varying on what he is doing. Faces his superior genome brother, Kuja. Kills him and prevents the destruction of existence itself.

Tidus-
Final Fantasy: X
Ultimate Weapon: Caladbolg(forgive me if I spelled it incorrectly)
Background: Lives in a "dream" world. An excillent blitz player, has a great hatred of his father. Also a little bit of a crybaby.
Quest: Swallowed by Sin, eventually becomes Yuna's guardian. Follows her to Zanarkand. Learns his about himself and the Fayth and his father.

Let the destruction and death begin!

A massive four-way brawl in which three individuals, brandishing powerful blades, face off to the death! Battle Participants Cloud Strife Final Fantasy: VII Ultimate Weapon: Ultima Weapon Background: Grew up in a small town called Nibleheim. Wishes to join SOLDIER. Never makes it. Used as a Sephiroth Clone by Professor Hojo. Fooled into believing he was in SOLDIER and given the memory of Zack. Quest: Travelling to defeat Sephiroth. No, being summoned by Sephiroth. Escapes his influence and defeats Sephiroth. Squall Leonhart- Final Fantasy: VIII Ultimate Weapon: Lionheart Background: Grew up in Edea Krammar's orphange on the Centra continent. Taken by Balamb Garden. Has a great rivalry with Seifer Almasy. Stoic and anti-social, he eventually losens up due to Rinoa's influence. Quest: Does a SeeD mission and gets sucked up into a giant plot by a sorceress from the future. Eventually exstinguishes the villain and that's all. Zidane Triball- Final Fantasy: IX Ultimate Weapon: Ultima Weapon Background: A specialized genome from another planet called Terra. Created by Garland, to be a "Angel of Death" to the people of Gaia. However, he forgets this and becomes a somewhat normal person. Quest: On attempting to kidnap the princess, he is sucked into the events around him. Travels from place to place, just following what has been happening, motives varying on what he is doing. Faces his superior genome brother, Kuja. Kills him and prevents the destruction of existence itself. Tidus- Final Fantasy: X Ultimate Weapon: Caladbolg(forgive me if I spelled it incorrectly) Background: Lives in a "dream" world. An excillent blitz player, has a great hatred of his father. Also a little bit of a crybaby. Quest: Swallowed by Sin, eventually becomes Yuna's guardian. Follows her to Zanarkand. Learns his about himself and the Fayth and his father. Let the destruction and death begin!

are you sure this doesn't belong in zelaron melee?oh well I think Cloud would win out of them.He is the toughest one and can use omnislash.

are you sure this doesn't belong in zelaron melee?oh well I think Cloud would win out of them.He is the toughest one and can use omnislash.

Omniownage for like it.

Squal, Tidus and Zidane are all fags compared to Cloud and thats final.

Zelaron Melee is designated for huge tournaments, not minor battles. It must be decided by Raziel and Titus whether or not this battle will occur. And since they're in the middle of a tournament right now, I don't think it will happen.


Cloud and Squall's stoic manners would help them. Zidane and Tidus can get serious, but they're really playful at heart. Tidus being stupid as he is would get knocked out early. He'd trip and fall or something like that.

In a straight fight, no tricks or preparation, Squall would win. Aura + Lionheart. He can use his Limit Break as many damned times as he wants. Cloud can only use his Omnislash when his Limit Meter is filled. That's a serious disadvantage.

If there was prep time allowed, It would be a close call between Zidane and Squall. Both are cunning and both could figure out very effective ways of outmaneuvering their opponents so they were the only two left.

Tidus would go out first because he'd spend the first five minutes of the fight complaining.

Cloud would go out second because he's a weak-willed sissy.

In the end, it would come down to Squall and Zidane, but I don't honestly think Zidane could win. It would take some serious planning to outmatch Squall.

No offense to him, but I don't think of Zidane as a great strategist.

And how do you figure that? He was the most respected member of Tantalus besides Baku, and they were one of the most notorious gangs of thieves in the world. You can't be a master thief and not be a cunning strategist. Squall is a military strategist, Zidane is a mercenary strategist. Squall's advantages lie in outmaneuvering an army, or team of opponents. Zidane's advantages lie in outmaneuvering a single opponent or a small group. Zidane has the obvious advantage in that situation.

Well, they never exactly showed he was a superb and cuning member of Tantalus. For all we know, it could've been Cinna who made all the plans.


Well, Squall's gunblade, being able to fire at an opponent, would come in handy. Zidane has to be near you. Squall can beat you from afar.

1) Technically, the same could be said for Squall. They never really showed him using any extreme tactical knowledge, it was just implied in his character.

2) Squall never showed the ability to use the Gunblade as a ranged weapon. The actual gun portion of the weapon is used to amplify the damage dealt with a melee attack. There's no way to even know if it would fire straight if he tried aiming it at someone and picking them off at a distance.

Well, Squall has discipline. He's been raised in a military institute.
Zidane can get serious, but it's not really in his nature.

Zidane has the advantage of havinga two-bladed weaon. He could block Squall with one ege and quickly rotate it and slash Squall with the other side.

Squall still has his magic powers. Zidane doesn't. Squall could just cast Ultima, Holy and Flare to beat the living hell out of Zidane.

And, I am just assuming, but I believe that Squall is the stronger of the two. No real proof, just something I think makes sense. Zidane looks to be more agile and quick, not a powerhouse.

And again, as I said, it would be an uphill battle the entire way in order for Zidane to beat Squall. Squall has the overwhelming advantage of power, combined with the fact that the Junction system allows Squall to become nearly unbeatable with the right magical combinations. But, bar none, out of the other three, Zidane would be the toughest opponent Squall would have to take down.

Agreed.


It cracks me up to think of Tidus in this fight. I can't stop smiling. What a loser he is.

He'd just start complaining and run away. Then he'd go home and frost his hair again.

Or somebody might call him "stupid" and he'd burst into tears, remembering his father.

This fight is concluded. Zidane is the champion. This was only a test though. I'm making a battle right after this one. Raziel, you'l probably be the opposition this time. I can't wait.....