He also said he had the game for a week when he played you. A 1:1 ratio will not make it in CAL leagues. I've seen people ask me if I think they're good enough when they're like 25:2. 1:1 sure as hell won't cut it.
You need to think about what you said, a 1:1 ratio is fine, if you are playing good people. I could go 25:1 and still not be good enough for cal-IM. I could go 1:2 and be cal-i.