|
|
|
 |
Posted 2004-01-31, 11:43 PM
in reply to Adrenachrome's post starting "I'm definitly seeing this movie now,..."
|
 |
 |
 |
I saw it last night, and I fucking loved it. I only had three complaints, but honestly they're a bit weird. I agreed with some decisions mostly, but was also a little let down by them:
SPOILERS AHOY!
1) There were a few moments in the movie where I felt that the absolute horror of the situation could have been displayed in more detail. Example: Kayleigh as the crackwhore. It just seemed like the directors should have pushed that entire sequence a bit further than they did. It just seemed a little too brief. Although, it makes sense that it was so short, considering the fact that she was so apprehensive about having anything to do with him at all.
2) The ending. I was honestly hoping that the entire situation was in his mind, as the last reality-sequence was suggesting. My jaw damn near dropped to the floor when his doctor told him that there never were any journals, and that they were all just a product of his coping mehcanisms, like his ability to alter his past. Although, I did like how they achieved the ending. Had Evan and Kayleigh ended up together and there was a friggin' rainbow at the end (ala Matrix: Revolutions) I would have been pissed off. However, by cutting Kayleigh out of his life entirely, he did the honorable thing and sacrificed his ideal life so everyone else wouldn't have to suffer.
3) This correlates with the ending again, and this is the only major complaint I have with the movie. How the hell did Evan survive at the end? In the last reality-sequence his brain had suffered innumerable and inescapable amounts of damage, and in the end he's doing fine? I figure that maybe because he cut all of those horrible moments out of his life entirely by cutting Kayleigh out entirely, that he completely averted the need to alter his past at all, and thus had removed the damage from his brain completely. But, that theory is negated by the fact that he still retained all of his now-false memories after altering the present, and it's the overload of memories on his brain that was causing the damage in the first place. If anyone has further insight on this one at all, it would be greatly appreciated.
SPOILERS NO MORE!
Aside from those three things, only one of which was anything close to "major", I thought it was fantastic. All of the acting was superb (including Kutcher), the story itself was great and it will certainly have my brain working overtime for the next couple of weeks.


Last edited by Raziel; 2004-02-01 at 07:25 AM.
|
 |
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|