To be perfectly honest, if I was a coach, and three girls came to me because another girl was bullying them (whether it be true or not), I'd wave them away. I've seen groups of girls fall out for daft reasons in the past.
But, if I knew the girls - maybe three bithces who like to scheme, and one who just tries to be friendly - I'd think something was going on.
Obviously your coach (male or female, btw?) is an idiot. How old are the other three girls?
Threaded Mode