Concept: The GravitonSurge system of approval!

Maybe set up a council who will decide what ppl they think are worthy of soa for example. Then they post a thread concerning this member and all other members can vote for or against. But dont make it a poll, instead make it a normal thread where the other members need to have some arguments for their choise, let that be open for 2 days and after that the council wil take all arguments into consideration and form the judgement.

As MasterAC said, there could be some sort of clause in this agreement that says under review of other council members, maybe say by a 3/5 vote, that the council can say another member on the council is not capable of making a clear and educated decision without being guided by their emotions. What I am trying to say, is if there were a council, certain members could be excluded from voting in certain situations. e.g. When determining what category Sovereign falls into, GravitonSurge might have to be taken out of the voting, because he has undeniable said that he hates him.

Ugh.. So many stipulations, questionable content, side bars, and alternate ideas. Heh, if you want, either myself, or someone else, can read all the ideas in this thread and put together a revised proposition.

One which covers the council makeup, a council vote, member vote, Staff exclusion, judging system (Categories, etc. for judging), place for deliberation, what Forums to judge members in (Exclude WRT and Chat?), back-up council ideas (Penny's 3/5 system?), actual rating system in full (SoA, GAHH, BLIS, etc.), how the ratings will be implemented, how often a members posts will get judged, which posts will initially be judged (Last 50 posts, 25 posts?), how a member can lose particular ratings (For the better or worse), etc.

Is there anything else I'm missing? Once the final list of everything needed for discussion is put together, as I have started above, I will start the draft, or others if they want.

Sounds sweet Titus. I think it would be a good idea to do your Admin thing and make the "revised" edition.

Get you admin groove on.

Man, I've never seen Zelaron so involved in something like this before. This has to go off without a hitch, it seems like. One mishap and it's the boot. You guys are precise.

Anyway, that previous paragraph has hidden subliminal messages that state, "Vote me into the council." Muah?

Well, so many people are getting involved because I am totally awesome.

Yes... that's it.... =\